The minimum 1918 nickel value is in a narrow $4.25 to $9 range. A good start and nice value, however with a closer look it's possible your Buffalo nickel is worth more.
The 1918 date is of special interest to collectors because of the possibility of finding a rare over date. Additionally, mintmarks and higher condition also increase value. Upon close examination...
The 1918 "S" listing is a coin minted in San Francisco, the "D" indicates Denver, and no mintmark was used by the Philadelphia mint.
Find mintmarks on the reverse below the mound along the rim. The four grade categories highlight values of better condition nickels. Also, how to identify the rare over date is covered in detail below.
|1918 Nickel Value|
|Condition of Coin|
|1918 Nickel Value Updated||2018|
Obvious and easily detectible even on a heavily worn coin, this over date error is considered a necessary addition to any serious Buffalo nickel collection.
The rarity of the over date and strong demand from both dealers and collectors has pushed the value of a nice example to over $2000.
When viewed side by side the over date is clear. Notice the "squaring" of the 8, caused by the sharp upper corner of the 7 Also, the 7 has caused partial filling of the top and bottom, normally round centers of the 8.
With the aid of a magnifying glass, locating the D mintmark, judging condition and always the possibility of identifying additional rarity combines to make any 1918 Buffalo nickel an exciting coin to evaluate.
As you sort through these old nickels, separate nicer quality ones from the rest and compare them to the "Grading" images. Judging their condition accurately identifies coins with potentially higher value.
Uncirculated: A sharp coin, appearing brand new. Collectors strive to own these rare coins. The uncirculated grade describes a nickel with no wear from use. As you rotate the coin under a light, wear would appear as breaks in luster, evident just below the eye of the Indian.
Extremely Fine: Slight reduction of details are noticeable. Design high points showing worn effects are the feathers, braid and hair on the obverse. Continue your examination on the reverse along the upper back of the buffalo. The separation of finer fur details is incomplete.
Fine: Once well rounded features are flattened in appearance. Places to study are the Indian's eyebrow, chin, and hair above the braid. Smooth spots have been created on the Buffalo's upper and lower legs, head and body, although a separation from one area to the next remains.
Good: The top edges of the lettering next to the rim have joined and blurred the distinction, noticeable on both obverse and reverse. Also defining the grade are extensive flat areas of the head, shoulder and hip across the Buffalo.
Buffalo Nickel Value
Check all your buffalo nickel values with the chart. Rising prices, increasing demand from both collectors and rare coin dealers requires a second look at your coins.
More Old Nickel Values
Including more relating to your 1918 nickel value. These early date Buffalo nickels are becoming valuable. Easily find how much your old coins are worth.
Covering the Nickel series from Shield nickels, Liberty, Buffalo and Jefferson nickels. All include value charts, along side grading images to find the accurate value of your old nickels.
Coin Values Discovery... finds the 1918 nickel value and... all old US coin values. It links to all coin series, from Cents to Gold. Value charts, images to judge the all important condition of coins, and a guide to getting the best deal if selling coins.
On occasion rare nickels do turn up... old better date buffalo nickels, valuable silver war nickels, even a few Jefferson nickels and others. Search your box of old coins and discover the possibilities of... Finding Rare Nickels